Fall Restaurant Week runs from Thursday, November 5, through Saturday, November 14. If you scan its 34 participants for the places that changed in the past year, how many different owners do you actually find? The four standouts are Buckley's on the Water, The Rosa, Nisi Greek Kitchen + Bar and Nichinan. Two owners are behind all four: Michael Timothy's Dining Group and restaurateur Jay McSharry. Michael Timothy's also has a third downtown project under way, and the chef behind Cure is close to opening a second restaurant. Read that way, the fall list tracks a handful of established operators adding addresses across the city.
Bow Street and State Street, one owner
In October 2025, the Portsmouth Herald reported that Michael Timothy's Dining Group would buy Martingale Wharf Restaurant and Bar and also The Rosa Restaurant. The former Martingale space at 99 Bow Street became Buckley's on the Water. The Herald reported in February 2026 that the group was aiming to open it by late April. The restaurant's own story page names owner Michael Buckley, Director of Culinary Operations Charlie Cicero and on-site Executive Chef Richard Deming. The Chamber Collaborative's fall dining roundup calls its deck "the largest dining deck in Portsmouth by far."
A few blocks along the waterfront at 70 State Street, The Rosa has been open since December 22, 1927. Its history page describes a structural remodel of the 1856 building into an open-concept interior and says Michael Timothy's Dining Group took over as owner in 2026. The Chamber's roundup notes updated menus and a larger bar.
Both restaurants are on the Restaurant Week list, and the shared ownership shows up in the menus. Both end with a warm blueberry crisp. The Chamber even hosts The Rosa's menu as a file named for both restaurants. The two menus split the work beyond dessert. The Rosa covers the Italian-American side, with Italian wedding soup, Mediterranean sea bass puttanesca, pork Milanese over rigatoni alla vodka and a shrimp scampi pizza. Buckley's covers the waterfront side, with sesame-seared tuna, braised beef or pan-roasted cod.
A West End plaza that came with its restaurant
McSharry took a different route. On November 17, 2025, the Seacoast restaurateur Jay McSharry finalized his purchase of the Gallagher's Place plaza in the West End. The Portsmouth Herald reported the sale at $7.4 million. The Herald also reported that McSharry would open Nisi, a Greek kitchen and bar, in the former Bob's Broiled Chicken unit. Instead of leasing a downtown space, he bought the plaza and opened in one of its units. Nisi was serving by April 2026, when the Union Leader reviewed it. Its press page names McSharry and chef Kevin Taillon.
Nisi has an older sibling downtown. Nichinan, at 15 Middle Street, opened in December 2022 as part of JGroup Hospitality, the collection McSharry founded, according to the restaurant's About page. The restaurant is named for Portsmouth's sister city in Japan. It isn't new, but the Chamber put it in the same fall roundup as Nisi, and the two are listed side by side for Restaurant Week.
What a course costs at each
The four menus differ in price, and they differ even more in the number of courses. That makes the per-course cost a useful comparison.
| Restaurant | Owner | Address | Fall 2026 Restaurant Week dinner | Cost per course |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nichinan | JGroup Hospitality, founded by Jay McSharry | 15 Middle Street | Five courses, $52 | About $10.40 |
| Nisi Greek Kitchen + Bar | Jay McSharry | 801 Islington Street | Four courses, $42 | $10.50 |
| The Rosa | Michael Timothy's Dining Group | 70 State Street | Three courses, $42 | $14.00 |
| Buckley's on the Water | Michael Timothy's Dining Group | 99 Bow Street | Three courses, $52 | About $17.33 |
McSharry's two restaurants work out to nearly the same cost per course, even though one sits in a West End plaza and the other on Middle Street downtown. Nichinan's five courses run from a persimmon-daikon salad through shrimp-and-tofu tempura, grilled black cod and pork ramen to matcha tiramisu. Nisi's four-course dinner includes a choice of village salad or fried cheese, pork gyro or chicken souvlaki, and baklava or rice pudding. Its menu also lists a Lemonodasos cocktail at $15.
The Michael Timothy's restaurants both serve three courses, $10 apart in price. The difference between them is the room. At Buckley's, the extra $10 pays for the Bow Street waterfront and that deck. At The Rosa, $42 gets a table in Portsmouth's oldest running restaurant, across the street from Prescott Park. If you want to try both owners in one week, you can do it for $84 with a Nisi dinner and a Rosa dinner, before drinks, tax and tip.
The next openings come from the same names
Penhallow Street shows that this isn't over yet. The Rosa's history page lists the group's other businesses, including Lost Cowboy Brewing and Buckley's Market & Café. According to the Chamber's fall roundup, the Market & Café space at 60 Penhallow Street is being turned into a Lost Cowboy taproom, with more live music, a bigger bourbon selection and games. A grand-opening announcement was expected later this fall. That puts a third Michael Timothy's project on the same block as Restaurant Week participants Ristorante Massimo at 59 Penhallow and Moxy at 106 Penhallow.
The other opening to watch also comes from someone already on the list. Julie Cutting-Kelley, the chef behind Cure at 189 State Street, is opening Char at 70 Maplewood Avenue. The Chamber describes it as a restaurant built around a large wood-burning grill, with steaks, cocktails and a lower-level piano lounge, and says Cutting-Kelley is bringing familiar Cure faces with her. In September the Chamber expected a fall opening. Char's website now says "Opening November 2026" and asks readers to watch for reservation details. Cure has its own Fall Restaurant Week menu this year, so Cutting-Kelley's current kitchen is on the list while her next one is still getting ready.
Booking the ten days
The ten days cover two weekends, and several participants leave weekend nights out. The Chamber notes these exceptions on its Restaurant Week page:
- Library Restaurant, 401 State Street: no Restaurant Week menu on Saturday.
- Louie's, 909 Islington Street: no Restaurant Week menu on Friday or Saturday.
- The Carriage House, 2263 Ocean Boulevard in Rye: no Restaurant Week menu on Friday or Saturday.
- Moxy, 106 Penhallow Street: bring a non-perishable food donation during Restaurant Week and get a dessert voucher for your next visit.
Louie's and Nisi are both on Islington Street, so a West End weeknight could start at either one. Nisi also has a Restaurant Week lunch menu, which makes it one of the few places on the list where you can try the new restaurant at midday. The Chamber says to book directly with each restaurant and to reserve early because tables fill quickly. For the four restaurants in the table, that means calling or booking through the websites linked above. Buckley's and The Rosa share an owner, but they are separate reservations.
At Brick & Barn Real Estate, we follow which owners are opening where in Portsmouth because it shapes how each block feels from one season to the next. If you'd like to talk through how downtown, the West End and Penhallow Street are changing, contact us.